Quick answer
An HEI is a good idea when you need cash, a monthly payment would strain your budget, and you expect modest home-price growth or plan to sell within the term. It's usually not the best choice if you can comfortably afford a HELOC payment and expect your home to appreciate at a normal pace, because sharing that appreciation can cost far more than interest.
The advantages of an HEI
No monthly payments
This is the main reason people choose an HEI. You get a lump sum and don't pay anything until you sell, refinance, buy out the investor, or reach the end of the term. For someone whose budget is already tight, that can be the difference between solving a problem and adding one.
No interest rate
Nothing compounds while you hold the HEI. If rates rise, your cost doesn't change. What you owe depends only on your home's value at settlement.
Easier qualifying
Credit requirements are generally lower than for a HELOC, with some providers accepting scores in the 500s, and there's no payment for your income to support. See HEI requirements.
The investor shares the downside
If your home's value falls, many contracts reduce what you owe along with it. A loan balance doesn't shrink when your home loses value.
Flexible use of the money
Debt payoff, a renovation, a business, medical bills, or a cushion during a career change. There are generally no restrictions on how you use the cash.
The drawbacks of an HEI
It can be expensive if your home appreciates
In our 10-year example on a $500,000 home, $50,000 from an HEI costs about $93,000 to settle at 3% annual appreciation and about $171,000 at 7%. The same $50,000 on an interest-only HELOC at an example 8% rate costs about $90,000 in that period.
Upfront fees
Typical fees run about 3–5% of the amount you receive, plus appraisal, title, and recording costs. Many HELOCs cost less to open.
A deadline at the end of the term
When the term ends (often 10–30 years), you have to settle, which may mean selling or refinancing if you don't have the cash. Plan ahead: see how to get out of an HEI.
Complex contracts
Investor share, starting value (risk adjustment), caps, and improvement credits all affect cost. Two offers that look similar can settle very differently.
It can limit future borrowing
The investor records a lien. Some lenders are cautious about adding a HELOC or refinancing behind or around an HEI, and the settlement amount must be paid off in a refinance.
Lump sum only
You receive all the money at once. If you need funds over time, a HELOC lets you draw only what you need.
Scorecard: HEI vs. HELOC
| HEI | HELOC | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | None | Yes |
| Cost if home values are flat | Usually lower | Interest still accrues |
| Cost if home values rise | Rises with the home | Usually lower |
| Credit flexibility | More flexible | Stricter |
| Upfront costs | About 3–5% plus third-party costs | Often low |
| Draw over time | No, lump sum | Yes |
| Keep all appreciation | No | Yes |
When an HEI is a good idea
- A monthly payment would strain your budget, and the cash solves a bigger financial problem.
- You plan to sell within the term, so settlement comes out of the sale.
- You expect modest appreciation where you live.
- Your credit or documentation keeps you from a HELOC right now.
- You're paying off high-interest debt to fix monthly cash flow.
When to look at something else
- You can afford a payment: a HELOC usually costs less over time.
- You're 62 or older: compare a reverse mortgage, which has no required monthly mortgage payment and no term deadline.
- You want a fixed payment: compare a home equity loan.
- You plan to stay 20+ years in a fast-appreciating area: the investor's share could be large.
How to reduce the risks if you choose an HEI
- Take only what you need. A smaller investment means a smaller share.
- Get the settlement amount in writing for flat, moderate, and strong appreciation.
- Choose a contract with a cap on total cost.
- Ask how improvements are credited, and keep receipts.
- Plan your exit years before the term ends.
Compare an HEI and a HELOC for your home
Tell us how much you need. We'll show the HELOC payment and total cost next to the HEI settlement under flat, moderate, and strong appreciation.
FAQ
Is a home equity investment a good idea?
It can be when you need cash without a monthly payment, expect modest appreciation, or plan to sell within the term. If you can afford a HELOC payment and expect normal appreciation, a HELOC usually costs less.
What are the biggest downsides of an HEI?
The cost can be high if your home appreciates quickly, upfront fees typically run about 3-5%, you must settle at the end of the term (possibly by selling or refinancing), and contracts can be complex.
What are the main advantages of an HEI?
No monthly payments, no interest rate, more flexible credit requirements than most loans, and in many contracts the investor shares in any decline in your home's value.
Can an HEI cost more than a HELOC?
Yes. In a 10-year example on a $500,000 home, $50,000 from an HEI costs about $93,000 at 3% annual appreciation and about $171,000 at 7%, compared with about $90,000 for an interest-only HELOC at an example 8% rate.
Is an HEI safer than a HELOC?
It removes the risk of missing monthly payments and of rising interest rates. It adds the risk of a large settlement if your home appreciates and a deadline at the end of the term. Which is safer depends on your budget and plans.
Talk to a licensed HELOC lender
Get a rate estimate or ask a question — direct answer from Audi Garner, Branch Manager & Broker (NMLS #190235). No sales pitch. No hard credit pull.
Get a 60-second rate estimate
Soft pull only. Written quote emailed within 1 business day.
Ask Audi a HELOC question
Direct answer from a licensed originator. Usually within 1 business day.
Keep reading
What Is an HEI? The Complete Guide
How HEIs work, what they cost, and the 10-year math vs. a HELOC.
HEI Requirements
Credit score, equity, and property rules.
How to Get Out of an HEI
Buyouts, refinancing, selling, and the end of the term.